Now Playing: Jedi: Survivor

I reviewed Jedi: Fallen Order back in 2020 and said – ‘I can’t say I didn’t enjoy playing Fallen Order but I also feel like the game doesn’t quite live up to its own potential. It’s the kind of game you’ll play but also be frustrated by because it just falls short in too many key areas.’ Well I’m pleased to say that this sequel – Survivor – is a perfect example of a sequel done right. It’s a game that addresses the flaws of the original whilst also building upon, expanding and refining everything that made the first game so good.

Jedi: Survivor picks up the story of Cal Kestis who has continued his fight against the Empire – a fight that feels increasingly futile. A fight that has also seen him lose touch with those closest to him. After an opening mission on Coruscant goes awry, Cal seeks out an old friend for help, which inadvertently sets Cal off on a new mission involving a hidden world that may serve as a safe refuge from the Empire.

Overall, I did like the story, but I do think it has a couple of problems. The first being how Cal just kind of falls into this plot by chance – he literally just stops somewhere to pick up some new ship parts and discovers some ancient Jedi technology nearby that sets him on a new path. Will of the Force? Eh, whatever.

I also don’t think the villains of Survivor are as strong as those in the original. Trilla was such a good antagonist in Fallen Order because she was a dark reflection of Cal. She represented what he could have become had he not escaped the Purge. But she was sadly underutilised within that game and I was really hoping they’d bring her back or at least hint of her return here – but sadly not. The villains in Survivor are fine, but none of their motivations quite added up for me or felt properly explored.

That said, what Survivor does so much better than the original is the development of our key characters. Cal feels much better realised here than in the original and I’m so glad they also gave more time to the supporting cast. All of the character stuff in Survivor is great, even though the overall plot – I would say – isn’t quite as compelling. It’s . . . fine, but I’d also say it’s unfortunately the weakest aspect of Survivor. I kind of want to dig into the plot more but it’s pretty difficult to say anything else without seriously spoiling things so I’ll leave the plot stuff here and move on.

In terms of gameplay, Survivor plays just like the original in the sense that it’s unashamedly derivative. But I do feel that Survivor does far more to create its own sense of identity. It cuts down significantly on the modern Tomb Raider / Uncharted climbing nonsense. Sure, there’s still a fair amount of platforming involved, but it’s not just climbing and jumping from wall to wall like the original was.

And whilst it retains the Metroid style map progression, Survivor has much better pacing in terms of ability unlocks and the overall map design is much more accessible in terms of revisiting areas. Whereas it could prove a bit of a chore returning to locations to explore in Fallen Order, Survivor makes it much easier – not to mention providing better reasons to explore with a significantly improved range of side content and cosmetic items to discover.

The Dark Souls style combat of Fallen Order has been significantly improved and expanded with more lightsaber styles, more combo moves and more force abilities – exactly what I asked for. In fact, it feels like everything I wanted and asked for in my review of Fallen Order has been addressed here.

The customisation options for Cal in Fallen Order were pretty terrible but they give you a fantastic selection of items here. It makes seeking out those unlocks all the more worthwhile. Not only are you exploring for fun, you’re also getting a neat reward at the end of it. The side content is also worth exploring with platform and combat challenges, Jedi puzzle rooms, bounty hunters to defeat, legendary creatures to kill and plenty of skill / health / force upgrades to discover.

There’s also a new ‘perk’ system that lets you further customise your combat style. These aren’t, admittedly, the most game changing kind of perks – they’re more about providing a small boost to certain things – but they’re a welcome addition nonetheless.

I also really liked the development of a location in the game that sees you ‘recruit’ people you meet on your travels and transform the location as a result. Unlike the first game which was very limited with its supporting cast, there’s a lot more characters to interact with in Survivor and developing this location adds yet more worth to your exploration beyond the core mission locations.

There’s just so much more content packed into Survivor and yet it doesn’t feel like they’ve bloated the game with unnecessary nonsense. Everything serves a purpose, everything feels worth your time and no matter where you go, you’ll always find something fun to fight, find or explore.

Visually, Survivor looks fantastic. The environments and effects and of course – the music – are all top notch. But I do have to address how shoddy this PC port of the game is. Survivor has a frame rate that just won’t behave. It doesn’t matter your hardware or your settings – it simply refuses to be stable.

I had a few crashes and sometimes when the game transitions into a cinematic it starts to stutter and you get a few freeze frames. It’s also ridiculous how the game has to ‘optimise’ files for 20-30 seconds every time you start it up. I don’t know what happened during development but something clearly was f**ked up. None of it is game breaking – just really annoying.

But, overall, I can’t deny that Jedi: Survivor is a fantastic sequel. Technical issues aside – and a plot that I didn’t find quite as compelling as the original – Survivor is a perfect example of how to do a sequel right. I really don’t have much, if anything else to say about it. There’s nothing really here I feel the need to criticise or complain about. Whereas Fallen Order didn’t quite live up to it’s own potential, Survivor does.

I really hope we’ll get a third game to round off this series. And if I must make a suggestion for the next one it would be – bring back Trilla! Oh, and don’t f**k up the PC port next time, please?

8/10

Gallery: Phantom Liberty (Part 1)

Now Playing: Ghostwire: Tokyo

I didn’t really know anything about Ghostwire: Tokyo going in but I certainly wasn’t expecting Far Cry with ghosts. Because that’s kind of what it is and I really wish it wasn’t. It feels like there’s a really good – maybe great – game buried in here beneath the layers of absolute shit. If you’ve followed this blog, you’ll know I’m not a fan of the Far Cry open world formula and GW:T adheres to that formula so strictly – and unnecessarily – that it makes me feel physically ill.

It’s such a f**king shame because there’s some great stuff in GW:T. So let’s get the negatives out of the way first, shall we? After an intriguing opening you are plunged into the open world of GW:T, and whilst I’m sure it’s a loving and presumably somewhat accurate representation of Tokyo, your heart will sink when you see your first radio tower . . . sorry, I mean shrine.

The map is covered by deadly ghost fog and you must ‘purge’ each and every shrine to clear the fog from the local area. This, in turn, unlocks the map and any local side quests in addition to vendors and other collectibles. So many f**king pointless collectibles. Now, I can’t say the Tokyo environment isn’t a nice change compared to the typical Far Cry rural / jungle themes, and I can’t say GW:T isn’t a very pretty game.

But what I can say is that traversing this open world is boring as f**k. You’ll rely heavily on fast travel to get around because there’s nothing fun or interesting about traversal. There are ways to rapidly ascend onto rooftops which you might think will allow you to parkour your way across the city. But no, that might be too fun. Instead, you just get a ‘float’ ability which lasts a few seconds, maybe long enough to reach a nearby rooftop.

Most of your traversal in GW:T will be slowly jogging from A to B. It’s almost like the game wasn’t designed with open world traversal in mind and all this unnecessary bullshit was added in later? Honestly, that’s what it feels like given how badly it’s structured within the game.

So, like Far Cry you get an extensive skill tree . . . that’s mostly just slight upgrades on abilities you unlock as you progress such as ‘do this 1 second faster’ or ‘increase radius of this by 1 metre’ or ‘carry 5 food items rather than 4’. It’s not exactly exciting stuff. You also get lots of collectibles to find like capsule toys, rare goods you can sell, graffiti art, world / lore notes, special spirit types and statues.

Oh, and 240 thousand spirits to collect that help you level up. Yes, you read that right. Thankfully they tend to be bunched together, so you can collect hundreds at a time, but even after finishing the game and unlocking the entire map after 15 hours of play, I still only had 80k in the bank. But then . . . what’s the point of these? I was Level 37 when I finished, despite not even collecting half the spirits and I still felt far too powerful for the last few chapters and boss fights that were far too easy as a result.

It’s almost like the game wasn’t balanced around all this additional open world shit. Or even balanced for an experience based level system. It’s kind of telling once you get to the end of Chapter 4 and realise the last 2 chapters take place entirely within a series of linear environments separate from the open world. It’s almost like the entire game was supposed to be a linear, more focused narrative driven action game but at some point someone decided to dump a terrible open world on top of it but they couldn’t apply it to the entire game. So they had to segregate the last few chapters.

The Far Cry feeling is really hammered home when the game gives you a bow and arrow . . . to fight ghosts. Oh, and a terrible ‘stealth’ system and ‘spirit vision’ to highlight objects and enemies within the world. F**k me, even writing about this makes me feel sick. You’ve got a completely unnecessary ‘Inventory’ of cosmetic clothing and a ‘Database’ full of useless information. And then you’ve got that map. That classic open world Far Cry map that looks like someone vomited icons all over it. And that f**king terribly bland UI.

The only good thing I can say about the open world is that the side quests are pretty good. Well . . . most of them. Some are just boring filler set within the open world, but many others actually take you to unique locations out of the open world – into a school, for example – and these small, linear, more focused missions are where the game really shines. It’s almost like . . . the game was designed for this kind of thing.

I don’t know if GW:T was designed with this open world in mind but it sure as f**k doesn’t feel like it. Everything about the open world sucks. It even ruins the enemy variety which, if GW:T was a smaller, more focused game, would probably be considered pretty good. But in the open world that spawns these f**king ghosts all over the place, you’ll soon get really sick of fighting the same five or six enemies over and over again.

I just can’t help but wonder if GW:T was originally built as a linear, focused 8 hour experience with no level system, no open world, no collectibles, no stealth system, no poor attempt at traversal mechanics and no f**king bow and arrow. I really want to play that game.

That said, the story and characters of GW:T aren’t all that great either. Our hero, Akito, is kind of a whiny git, and his relationship with his spirit guide – KK – ain’t no V and Johnny Silverhand. There’s a couple of moments of good banter and a couple of nice emotional beats, but nothing particularly memorable.

As for the combat, ignoring the bow – that actually makes the game way too easy – you also have magical attacks you can shoot like finger guns based on Wind, Water and you guessed it – Fire. It’s stylish and kind of fun to mix it up during battles, but it’s also undeniably shallow and lacks any real depth. And pretty much all enemies are defeated the same way – by pounding on them until their ‘core’ is exposed and then ripping it out. Once again, in a shorter, more focused game I’d say it was fine, but you really get to see just how shallow, repetitive and broken (with stealth and the bow) combat is the longer the game drags on.

Is that enough ranting? Okay, time for the good stuff. I really liked the focus on Japanese folklore and urban legends and spirits and all that cool cultural stuff that gives the game a unique feel. It also – because of that – has some cool enemy designs. And those smaller, more linear and focused side missions really are great.

The ones that really lean into the spooky horror element as the environment and reality warps around you. All of that stuff is a lot of fun and I wish there was more of that within the game. Unfortunately, you have to wade through so much tedious open world bullshit to unlock and get to those side missions.

And . . . yeah, I don’t have many more positive things to say about GW:T. Now, I know not everyone is as absolutely sick of the Far Cry formula as I am, so maybe you won’t have quite such an adverse reaction. But that said, GW:T is, to me, a game that does not feel like it was designed with it in mind. It feels like something shoved in needlessly to pad out a short, more focused experience.

I wouldn’t say it ruins the game – because you can focus just on the core quests if you want and do your best to ignore all that other shit. So no, it doesn’t ruin it, but it does make we wonder just how good GW:T could have been without it. If this had just been a smaller, more focused experience. Because once you strip out all the bullshit, there is a pretty good game buried in here and I can’t say I didn’t have some fun on those few occasions I was able to dig it out.

5/10

Forbidden West: First Impressions

I loved Horizon: Zero Dawn so as you can probably guess, I was super excited to play its sequel when it eventually made its way to PC. It sure took its damn time, and avoiding spoilers for going on 2 years hasn’t always been easy, but I was able to go into Forbidden West largely blind. And I’m glad to say that that this port – unlike the The Last of Us – is incredibly well done. In fact, it’s probably the best PlayStation to PC port yet.

Forbidden West looks absolutely stunning and it runs super smooth. Even without frame generation enabled I’m clocking an average 150 FPS at 1440p. I can’t remember the last time I stopped to take so many damn screenshots or use the photo mode – expect at least two Gallery posts for Forbidden West, maybe more.

Visuals and port quality aside, I can’t say I didn’t go into Forbidden West a tad apprehensive. Because whilst I had avoided any big story or gameplay spoilers, I had seen a general sentiment expressed that the game was great, but maybe not quite as great as the original – with the story going in a direction it seemed some players didn’t like?

I can’t really comment on where the plot goes yet, but I’m certainly not disappointed by what I’ve seen so far. I’m about 20 hours in although I must admit, most of that time hasn’t been spent on the main quest, but on simply exploring the fantastic world. I really like the map design so far, because not only is it clearly marked into individual regions, but those regions have their own ‘natural’ borders within – rivers, cliffs, terrain types – breaking each region into more manageable chunks.

It makes it easier to focus my own exploration so I never feel overwhelmed. I can set my own limits and know exactly how far I want to press. And that’s an important and perhaps somewhat overlooked aspect of open world design – building a map that offers the player not only scale but direction. Very few open world games get it right, but from what I’ve seen so far, Forbidden West nails it. It also makes my exploration feel rewarding as I’ve always found something neat at the end of every path – obvious or not.

Gameplay wise, Forbidden West isn’t a significant departure from Zero Dawn. It plays largely the same but with just more stuff. More weapons. More ammo types. More abilities. More robots. There are new traversal and exploration tools to unlock, although I’ve only got a couple of these so far. I am a little concerned that they might have gone a little over the top with the alternative robot types though.

The game has new elemental damage types in addition to the old, and more machines come in alternative variations with different weaknesses or abilities related to specific parts. I wouldn’t say this is a bad thing, more a concern for how much there will be to keep track of as I progress. You really have to spend more time scanning a machine pack to nail down exactly what version – or versions – of that machine you’re dealing with and therefore what they’re vulnerable or resistant to and where their weak spots are.

I mean, I love that the game gives me so many options in terms of weapons and tools, but the game already feels like it’s overcomplicating some things more than it needs to and I’m already questioning how useful or necessary some of these things – like the new ammo types – really are. But I guess we’ll see how it shakes out over the entire game.

Melee combat has had a welcome overhaul although it still feels rather random and imprecise. The new skill tree system is neat and lets you unlock a lot of cool stuff that lets you customise how you want to play or the kind of weapons you want to focus on. I also like the new weapon / armour system and I appreciate being able to set a different ‘visual’ armour to that which I’m currently equipped. It means I can spend resources upgrading my preferred set, but also be able to change how Aloy looks as and when I please without worrying about the loss in stats or skills.

Oh, and did I mention how pretty the game looks? The character models are top notch and the VA is excellent. And I almost forgot – Aloy can now swim. I’m limited how long I can stay underwater at the moment, but I suspect I’ll find an item to improve that at some point in the game. It really adds a cool new layer to the experience.

Overall, I’m thoroughly enjoying my time with Forbidden West. It’s expanded. It’s refined. It might – though it’s too soon to say – have overcooked a few aspects, but I can’t pass judgement on those until I’m finished. I’m going to take my time and enjoy this one.